Designing Better Discussions in an AI World
Discussion boards have never been about simply posting answers—they've been about making sense of ideas together. In an AI-rich world, that distinction matters more than ever. Rather than making discussion prompts harder, instructors can design discussions that emphasize reasoning, judgment, and meaningful interaction. By focusing on visible thinking, social metacognition, and thoughtful use of AI, discussions can become powerful opportunities for students to challenge assumptions, refine their understanding, and develop the kinds of judgment that AI cannot easily replace.
Making Student Thinking Visible
AI has not changed what learning is, but it has exposed how difficult it can be to see. Too often, we assess the final product without understanding the thinking that produced it. In an AI-rich world, instructional design must shift toward making reasoning, decision-making, and reflection visible. Small changes, such as asking students to justify their choices or explain their process, can provide richer evidence of learning while helping students develop the metacognitive skills that matter most.
Start With One Assignment, Not Your Entire Course
AI has exposed a challenge that may have existed long before generative AI: a completed assignment is not necessarily the same thing as evidence of learning. Rather than redesigning an entire course, faculty can begin with a single assignment and ask a simple question: What evidence of learning am I actually looking for? Small changes that make student thinking more visible can often have a surprisingly large impact.